Cakes & Pies

Both Nona's locations offer custom made cakes and pies as well as a selection of pre-made cakes.  Our custom order cakes require at least 72 hours notice and with any Sunday or Monday cake orders to be ordered by Thursday afternoon. Custom cakes can be ordered over the phone or in person. At this time, we are not setup to accept cake orders via email.  For all cakes to be picked up in Hingham, please call 781-749-3999.  Please call 781-378-1464 for a cake to be picked up at our Scituate store.  Our pre-made cakes are available for same-day pickup.  In January and February our Scituate store is closed Monday through Wednesday so please plan accordingly.

 

Our cakes can be made with 1 or 2 ice cream flavors, normally in two layers separated by a layer of chocolate cookie crunch. We also offer ice cream pies, which are made in a chocolate or graham cracker crust. 

 

Our newest creation is the Nona's Tortina! Our ice cream cupcake. It is two layers of ice cream separated by a layer of cookie crunch topped with cool whip! These adorable mini cakes come in packs of four. 

 

Sizes:

Junior                           Serves 1-2 people                      $9.95

6"                                  Serves 6-8 people                      $22.95

8"                                 Serves 10-14 people                    $32.95

10"                               Serves 20-25 people                    $44.95

Pie                                 Serves 6-8 people                     $17.50

Tortina 4 pack              Serves 4 people                       $14.95

While we make over 100 flavors, we don't always have them available for cakes, particularly seasonal flavors. The following flavors are always available for cake orders (made within our 72-hour order window).

Vanilla

Chocolate

Chocolate chip

Cookie Dough

Oreo

Coffee

Coffee Oreo

Mint Chocolate Chip

Black Raspberry

Black Raspberry Chip

Vanilla M&M

Fudge Ripple

Chocolate M&M

Chocolate Oreo